2 views
by
Compare RTD and Thermistor

2 Answers

0 votes
by

RTD
Thermistor
RTD is made up of metals.
Thermistor is made up of semiconductor Materials
Metals have Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) of resistance. Hence the resistance of RTD increases with an increase in temperature and decreases with a decrease in temperature
Semiconductor materials have Negative Temperature Coefficient (NTC) of resistance. Hence, the resistance of a thermistor decreases with an increase in temperature and increases with a decrease in temperature.
The resistance temperature characteristics of RTD's are linear.
The resistance temperature characteristics of thermistor are highly nonlinear. 
It is less sensitive to temperature compared to thermistor.
It has large temperature coefficient of resistance i.e. thermistor highly sensitive to temperature compared to RTD. 
It has-a wide operating temperature range i.e., minus 200 to plus 650°C.
It has low operating temperature range compared to RTD i.e., minus 100 to plus 300°C.
RTD's provide high degree of accuracy and long term stability
Thermistors provide less degree of accuracy and short term stability
They have low selfresistance.
They have high self-resistance. Thus, they require shielding cables to minimize interference problems. 
RTD's are relatively larger in size. They are costlier as compared to thermistor.
Size of thermistors is small. They are not costlier as compared to RTD
0 votes
by

RTD
Thermistor
Made of metals which are good conductors of electricity e.g. copper, platinum Nickel
Made of metallic oxides such as cobalt, manganese, nickel etc.
Positive temperature coefficient of resistance.
PTC and NTC both types are available
Temperature range: -100 C to 650 C.
Temperature range: -50 C to 300 C
It has linear temperature versus resistance curve.
It has nonlinear temperature versus resistance curve.
As made of metal they are more stable.
As made of metal oxide they are less time stable.
They have better reproducibility and low hysteresis.
They have less reproducibility and more hysteresis.
Relatively bigger in size.
Thermistors are quite small in size.
Cost is high 
They are not costlier as compared to RTD
Welcome to Electrical Engineering Questions and Answers site. You are free to ask any questions and answer any questions...

Categories

Most popular tags

power motor dc circuit voltage transformer current used system phase resistance factor load synchronous energy ac induction generator electric series frequency capacitor use speed between electrical meter line type mosfet control transmission difference magnetic plant high single instrument bjt source advantages function diode machine unit winding torque field parallel amplifier define supply thyristor motors arduino shunt maximum relay armature problem electricity time and value on transformers types coil diagram state flow ratio material three starting direction theorem method emf formula operating efficiency digital wave microprocessor test instruments loss measure operation connected low applications effect single-phase working losses different network law wattmeter inductance temperature measuring constant signal controlled breaker device full compare flux drive wire resistivity logic rc materials machines angle force switch disadvantages converter transistor gain protection scr core measurement number free bridge principle generators reactance circuits negative friction open pole conductor conservation steam iron loop resistors hysteresis short computer using lines secondary station battery rectifier inverter linear induced relays nuclear regulation design analog work rotor electronics gate forces diesel damping rlc connection factors capacitance capacitors minimum insulation basic moving running self systems air fault range direct main stability quality starter igbt eddy ideal ammeter rl 3-phase plants arc thermal error fuzzy biasing dielectric pressure balanced superposition errors rotation characteristics feedback impedance measured electronic inductive start alternator off back curve over solar average three-phase tariff locomotive peak bias zener commutator surge rating universal potentiometer density permanent mechanical copper transducer capacity electrons memory adc excitation transfer explain fuse pure harmonics application of inductor internal pmmc reaction welding resonance traction permeability breakers rms designed electromagnetic engineering si generation brushes switching capacitive shaded rate distribution methods delta star oscillator reluctance semiconductor simplification algebra 8085 boolean weston dynamometer insulating strength installation definition fuel heating earth units neutral rated conductors coefficient filter controller usually reverse
...